San Diego Superior Court - Central District

CALIFORNIA VALLEY MIWOK TRIBE

VS.

THE CALIFORNIA GAMBLING CONTROL COMMISSION

37-2008-00075326-CU-CO-CTL

Location: Hall of Justice
330 West Broadway #1100
San Diego, California 92101
http://www.sdcourt.ca.gov/

Case Type: Civil Date Filed: 01/08/2008
Category: CU-CO / Case Status: Pending
Case Category: Civil - Unlimited Location: Central
Case Type: Contract - Other Judicial Officer: Ronald L. Styn

Docket: http://www.sdcourt.ca.gov/

Case Search -> Case Number Search -> Case Type = Civil, Case Location = San Diego, Case Number, Submit -> Register of Actions

Tentataive Rulings

http://www.sandiego.courts.ca.gov/v3tr/scsdrulings.aspx

Department 62 Policies and Procedures - Honorable Ronald L. Styn
Central
Honorable Ronald L. Styn, Presiding
Department 62 Staff
Court Clerk: Kimberly Mulligan
Calendar Clerk: Pat Woods
Reporter: Susan Holthaus
Staff Attorney: Kerry Kawamura

Phone numbers
Courtroom (619) 450-7062
Calendar (619) 450-7050

Court Call - say "Pat Woods" said it is okay: instructions and 888-882-6878 (2).

Court Business Office (Civil) M-F 8:30-3:30 (619) 450-7275

 

Transcripts: Sue Holthaus 619-450-7040 sholthaus1@san.rr.com

Sue L. Holthaus, CSR 6959
San Diego Superior Court
330 W. Broadway
Department 62
San Diego, California 92101

 

San Diego Service of Process, LLC / 2445 Morena Blvd., Ste. 201 / San Diego, California 92110
Phone(s): (888) 838-8845, (619) 275-6400 Fax Number: (619) 275-6420 Email: service@sdsop.com (Jill)

WebSite: http://www.sandiegoserviceofprocess.com

(Filing fee of $35 plus check for any court fees. 3 copies for court. 1 set of documents per party served. Complete Order from on web-site for the Court and one for each Party served.)

History of filing: In the morning of 11-08-2010 the Process Server takes Notice of Motion and P&A to the Department; the Department directs them to to the Clerk, the Clerk then sends the Pleadings to the Motion Clerk, where it is being processed. In the afternoon of 11-08-2010, the Server files the Notice of Lodgement and that gets processed and posted to the web-site.

2008-07-28   Plaintiff 1st Amended Complaint
08/18/2010   Court Case reassigned to Ronald Styn effective
08/18/2010
08/23/2010   Court Civil Case Management Conference
scheduled for 09/24/2010 at 10:00:00 AM at
Central in C-62 Ronald L. Styn.
09/02/2010   Court Civil Case Management Conference
rescheduled to 10/01/2010 at 10:00:00 AM
in C-62 before Ronald L. Styn at Central.
09/02/2010   Court Civil Case Management Conference
scheduled for 10/01/2010 at 10:00:00 AM at
Central in C-62 Ronald L. Styn.
10/01/2010   Court Civil Jury Trial scheduled for 05/13/2011 at
09:30:00 AM at Central in C-62 Ronald L.
Styn.
10/01/2010   Court Trial Readiness Conference (Civil)
scheduled for 06/06/2011 at 09:30:00 AM at
Central in C-62 Ronald L. Styn
10/01/2010   Court Civil Jury Trial scheduled for 05/13/2011 at
09:30AM before Judge Ronald L. Styn.
10/01/2010   Court Trial Readiness Conference (Civil)
scheduled for 06/06/2011 at 09:30AM
before Judge Ronald L. Styn.
10/01/2010   Court Jury demanded by plaintiff and defendant.
10/01/2010   Court Case file location changed to Hall of
Justice C-Civil Business Office (Rm 225)
10/01/2010   Court Minutes finalized for Civil Case
Management Conference heard 10/01/2010
10:00:00 AM
2010-10-14   Defendant Answer
10/15/2010   The California Gambling Control
Commission (Defendant)		 Answer filed by The California Gambling
Control Commission.
10/22/2010   Court Summary Judgment / Summary
Adjudication (Civil) scheduled for
01/28/2011 at 08:30:00 AM at Central in C-62
Ronald L. Styn
10/28/2010   Court Motion Hearing (Civil) scheduled for
12/17/2010 at 08:30:00 AM at Central in C-62
Ronald L. Styn.
11/01/2010   California Valley Miwok Tribe
(Plaintiff)		 Motion for Summary Judgment and/or
Adjudication (and supporting
declarations) filed by California Valley
Miwok Tribe.
11/02/2010   Court Civil Jury Trial rescheduled to 06/03/2011
at 09:30:00 AM in C-62 before Ronald L.
Styn at Central.
11/02/2010   Court Civil Jury Trial scheduled for 06/03/2011 at
09:30:00 AM at Central in C-62 Ronald L.
Styn.
11/08/2010   California Valley Miwok Tribe
(Plaintiff)		 Notice of Lodgment (of order for motion to
intervene) filed by California Valley Miwok
Tribe.
11/08/2010   Intervenors Motion for Leave to Intervene filed by
California Valley Miwok Tribe California;
Dixie, Yakima K; Whitebear, Velma; Lopez,
Antonia; Azevedo, Antone; Mendibles,
Michael; Wilson, Evelyn.
    Notice-of-Motion  Notice of Motion and Motion to Intervene
    Memorandum of Points and Authorities  Argument
    Declaration-Dixie
    Declaration-WhiteBear  
    Declaration-Lopez  
    Declaration-Mendibles  
    Declaration-Azevedo  
    Declaration-Wilson  
    Declaration-Everone  
    Proposed-Order  
    Proposed-Complaint  
    Exhibit-A 1915-08-13-SheepRanch
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1965-SheepRanch
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966-02-03.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966-02-09.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966-08-18-MabelHodgeDixie.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966-08-23.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966a-SheepRanchDoc.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966b-SheepRanchDoc.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966c-SheepRanchDoc.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1965-12-30.pdf
    Exhibit-C Exhibit-C-1925-00-00-Kroeber.pdf
    Exhibit-D Exhibit-D-2007-04-02-RegionToBurley.pdf
    Exhibit-E Exhibit-E-2010-09-10-Litigations.pdf
    Exhibit-F Exhibit-F-2005-02-11-BIA-Determination.pdf
    Exhibit-G Exhibit-G-2004-03-26-BIAtoBurley.pdf
    Exhibit-H Exhibit-H-2005-09-05-Yakima-Disenrolled.pdf
    Exhibit-I Exhibit-I-2007-04-11-BIA-PublicNotice-AmadorLedgerDispatch.pdf
    Exhibit-J Court case -not posted
    Exhibit-K Court case -not posted
    Exhibit-L Court case -not posted
    Exhibit-M Court case -not posted
    Exhibit-N  
11/09/2010   Court Trial Readiness Conference (Civil)
rescheduled to 05/06/2011 at 09:30:00 AM
in C-62 before Ronald L. Styn at Central.
11/09/2010   Court Trial Readiness Conference (Civil)
scheduled for 05/06/2011 at 09:30:00 AM at
Central in C-62 Ronald L. Styn
11/09/2010   Court Civil Court Trial rescheduled to 05/13/2011
at 09:30:00 AM in C-62 before Ronald L.
Styn at Central.
11/09/2010   Court Civil Court Trial scheduled for 05/13/2011
at 09:30:00 AM at Central in C-62 Ronald L.
Styn
11/22/2010   Court Proof of Service (Civil Case Cover Sheet;
Declarations; Applicant Intervenors' Memo
of P&As [ Terry Ladell Singleton served])
filed by The California Gambling Control
Commission.
11/22/2010   Defendant -The California Gambling Control
Commission		 Proof of Service (Civil Case Cover Sheet;
Declarations; Applicant Intervenors Memo
of P&As[ Manuel Corrales, Jr. served]) filed
by The California Gambling Control
Commission.
12/02/2010   Plaintiff - California Valley Miwok Tribe Opposition to Noticed Motion and
Supporting Declarations (to motion to
intervene) filed by California Valley Miwok
Tribe.
     
2010-12-10   Defendant -The California Gambling Control
Commission		 Defendant Objection to Plaintiff's Judicial Notice
2010-12-10   Intervenor Intervenor Reply to Opposition
2010-12-16   Court Court tentative ruling in favor of Intervention
2010-12-17   Court Hearing - court sustains tentative ruling.
       
       
2011-09-06   Plaintiff Ex Parte Papers Entry Judgement.
2011-09-06   Plaintiff Request for Judicial Notice of Determination of AS-IA
2011-09-07   Defendant Opposition-to-Ex-Parte.pdf

Below are the original proceedings which were obviated by change of jurisdiction

 50
 
2008-09-02

 51
 Defendant Demurrer
2008-09-02

 52
 Defendant Points.and.Authorities
2008-09-02

 53
 Defendant Request.for.Judicial.Notice.pdf
   
2008-09-12

 54
 Amicus Curiae Application.Leave.Amicus_PMedits.doc
2008-09-12

 55
 Amicus Curiae AmicusBrf.SuppDemurrer.2.doc
   
2008-10-02

 56
 Amicus Curiae Letter to Judge Lewis
   
2008-10-07

 57
 Plaintiff Opposition to Amicus of 2008-09-12
   
2008-10-21

 58a
 Plaintiff Plaintiff's Supplemental Opposition Amicus Curiae
 
2008-11-28  58b Plaintiff Points- Authorities in Opp'n to Demurrer to FAC
       
2008-12-12

58c
 BIA Letter on tribal status by BIA to Attorney General
       
2008-12-12

 59
 Court Tentative Ruling
   
2008-12-23

 60
 Court Court isssues an Order Sustain Demurrer and Effectively Dismissing the case.
   
2009-01-06

61 a
 Plaintiff-Burley Supplemental Brief
2009-01-06

 61 b
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-01-10.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 c
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-11-12.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 d
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-13.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 e
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-14-15.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 f
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-17.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 g
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-18-20.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 h
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-21-24.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 i
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-25-26.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 j
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-27a.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 k
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-27b.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 l
 Plaintiff-Burley Woodward-Decl-Part-1.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 m
 Plaintiff-Burley Woodward-Decl-Part 4.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 n
 Plaintiff-Burley Woodward-Decl-Part 5.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 o
 Plaintiff-Burley Declaration-Corrales-Skibine.pdf
   
2009-01-16  62 Defendant Answer
   
2009-03-05   Court Order Sustaining Demurrer Without Leave to Amend

 

 

 

 

United States District Court

for the Southern District of California

Case #08-CV-0120 BEN AJB

General: http://www.casd.uscourts.gov/

Calendar: http://www.casd.uscourts.gov/index.php?page=calendars

PACER: https://ecf.casd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/ShowIndex.pl
Date & Link

#
 Agent Explanation
   
2008-01-07   1 Plaintiff-Burley Burley Complaint - - The case was originally file on 2008-01-07 in Superior Court of the State of California For the Countyof San Diego - Central District. Then the Defendant had it removed to Federal Court in Sourthern District.
   
2008-01-22  2 Defendant-State Notice Of Removal to Federal Court
       
2008-01-31-(4.0)  3 Defendant-State Motion for Change of Venue
2008-01-31  4 Defendant-State Motion To Dismiss
2008-01-31-(4.2)  5 Defendant-State Notice of Motion for Change of Venue
2008-01-31  6 Defendant-State Notice of Motion
2008-01-31-(4.3)  7 Defendant-State Points and Authorities in Support of Motion for Change of Venue.pdf
2008-01-31  8 Defendant-State Points and Authorities in Support of Motion to Dismiss
   
2008-02-01-(6)  9 Plaintiff-Burley Notice-Dismissal of portions of original complaint of 2008-01-07
   
2008-02-06-(7)  10 Plaintiff-Burley Response
2008-02-06-(8)  11 Plaintiff-Burley Motion To Remand
     
2008-02-09  12 Court Docket
       
       
 2008/03/18  13 Court Discrepancy Order by Judge Roger T. Benitez accepting document: Ex Parte MOTION Leave to Respond 18 from Plaintiff California Valley Miwok Tribe, non-compliance with local rules. Signed by Judge Roger T. Benitez on 03/18/08. (joeh) (Entered: 03/18/2008)

 

The above case and documents are transferred to Federal Court Eastern District of California (Sacramento)
United States Courthouse, 501 "I" Street, Sacramento, 95814

 

U.S. District Court
Eastern District of California (Sacramento)
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 2:08-cv-00984-WBS-GGH

California Valley Miwok Tribe v. California Gambling Control Commission
Assigned to: Judge William B. Shubb
Referred to: Magistrate Judge Gregory G. Hollows
Case in other court: US District Court, Southern District of CA, 3:08-cv-0120 BEN AJB
Cause: 28:1362 Indian Tribal Controversy
Date Filed: 05/06/2008
Jury Demand: None
Nature of Suit: 190 Contract: Other
Jurisdiction: Federal Question
Plaintiff
California Valley Miwok Tribe represented by Manuel Corrales, Jr.
Law Offices of Manuel Corrales, Jr.
11753 Avenida Sivrita
San Diego, CA 92128
858-521-0634
Fax: 858-521-0633
Email: mannycorrales@yahoo.com
LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Terry Singleton
Singleton and Associates
1950 5th Street
Suite 200
San Diego, CA 92101
619-239-3225
Fax: 619-702-5592
Email: terry@terrysingleton.com
LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Internet Site - General

Local Rules

Calendar

PACER
05/06/2008

 14
 Defendant-State Notice of Removal of Civil Action
05/06/2008

 14a
 Defendant-State Motion to Dismiss the Complaint for Injunction relief, Declaratory Relief, Breach of Contract, Breach of Fiduciary Duty and Intentional Interference with Prospective Economic advanatage, or, in the Alternative, to Stay Proceedings.
   
05/06/2008

 15
 Plaintiff - Burley Opposition to Defendant's Motion for Change of Venue to the Eastern District of California, Sacramento Division
   
05/06/2008

 16
 Court Docket.
05/06/2008

 17
 Court Order Setting Status (Pretrial Scheduling Conference)
05/06/2008

 18
 Court Notice of Availability of a Magistrate Judge to Exercise Jurisdiction and Appeal Instructions
05/06/2008

 19
 Court Notice of Availability - Voluntary Dispute Resolution
05/08/2008

 20
 Court Order Permitting Plaintiff's Counsel to Attend June 23, 2008 Hearing Telephonically.
   
05/08/2008

 21
 Plaintiff - Burley Amended - Notice of Hearing and Motion to Remand Back to State court; Memorandum of Points and Authorities.
05/08/2008

22
 Plaintiff - Burley Ex parte Application for an order permitting Plaintiff's Counsel to Attend Hearing Telephonically; Proposed Order
   
05/09/2008

 23
 Defendant-State Amended - Notice of Motion to dismiss the Complaint for Injunctive Relief, Declaratory Relief, Breach of contract, Breach of Fiduciary Duty and Intentional Intereference with prospective economic advantage or in the alternative to stay proceedings.
   
2008-06-02

 24
 Intervenor - Dixie MOTION to INTERVENE by Yakima K. Dixie, Melvin Dixie.
 2008-06-02

 25
  Intervenor - Dixie Proposed Order.
 2008-06-02

 26
  Intervenor - Dixie  Memorandum of Points and Authorities
 2008-06-02

 27
  Intervenor - Dixie  Appendix 1 - Act of August 18, 1958
 2008-06-02

 28
  Intervenor - Dixie  Appendix 2 - Order denying previous Intervention
 2008-06-02

 29
  Intervenor - Dixie  Exhibit A - 1915 Census
 2008-06-02

 30
  Intervenor - Dixie  Exhibit B - 1965 Vote by Mable Dixie
 2008-06-02

 31
  Intervenor - Dixie  Exhibit C - Kroeber's Handbook
 2008-06-02

 32
  Intervenor - Dixie  Exhibit D - Declaration of Yakima
 2008-06-02

 33
  Intervenor - Dixie  Exhibit-F - Olsen Mandate
 2008-06-02

 34
  Intervenor - Dixie  Exhibit-E - Declaration of Melvin
 2008-06-02

 35
  Intervenor - Dixie  Exhibit G - Silvia's disenrollment of Yakima
 2008-06-02

 36
  Intervenor - Dixie  Exhibit-H - Silvia's disenrollment of Yakima
 2008-06-02

 37
  Intervenor - Dixie  Exhibit-I - Public Notice of organization
 2008-06-02

 38
  Intervenor - Dixie  Proposed Answer
   
 2008-06-12

 39
  Court MINUTE ORDER (TEXT ONLY): The parties are hereby notified that item 4 Plaintiff's Motion to Remand to State Court and item 7 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss are continued from 6/23/2008 to 7/7/2008 at 02:00 PM in Courtroom 5 (WBS) before Judge William B. Shubb. (Kirksey Smith, K) (Entered: 06/12/2008)
   
 2008-06-18

 40
  Court Order regarding timing of hearings.
 
 2008-06-24

 41
  Defendant-State  Stipulated change in hearing date.
   
 2008-06-26

 42
  Court Order continuing Hearing to July 21, 2008 @ 2 P.M. Department 5, Judge Shubb
   
 2008-07-02

 43
 Plaintiff - Burley Plaintiff's Opposition To Intervenor
   
 2008-07-13

44
  Intervenor - Dixie Intervenor- Tribe Reply in Opposition to Intervention
 2008-07-13

 45
  Intervenor - Dixie Tribe-Reply-Opposition-ExAA
 2008-07-13

 46
  Intervenor - Dixie Tribe-Reply-Opposition-ExBB
   
 2008-07-21

 47
  Court  MINUTES (Text Only) for proceedings held before Judge William B. Shubb: MOTIONS HEARING held on 7/21/2008. Court takes the following matters UNDER SUBMISSION: 4 Plaintiff's Motion to Remand to State Court; 7 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss; and 8 Movant-Intervenor Yakima Dixie and Melvin Dixie's Motion to Intervene as Paty Defendants. Plaintiffs Counsel Manuel Corrales, Terry Singleton present via telephone. Defendants Counsel Peter Kaufman present. Tim Vollman counsel for Intervenor present. Court Reporter/CD Number: Kathy Swinhart. (Kirksey Smith, K) (Entered: 07/21/2008)
   
 2008-07-24

 48
  Court  Order Remanding to State Court
 2008-07-24

 49
  Court  Judgement

 

San Diego Superior Court - Central District

CALIFORNIA VALLEY MIWOK TRIBE

VS.

THE CALIFORNIA GAMBLING CONTROL COMMISSION

37-2008-00075326-CU-CO-CTL

The Hall of Justice
330 West Broadway
San Diego, California 92101
http://www.sdcourt.ca.gov/
2008-07-28

 50
 Plaintiff 1st Amended Complaint
 
2008-09-02

 51
 Defendant Demurrer
2008-09-02

 52
 Defendant Points.and.Authorities
2008-09-02

 53
 Defendant Request.for.Judicial.Notice.pdf
   
2008-09-12

 54
 Amicus Curiae Application.Leave.Amicus_PMedits.doc
2008-09-12

 55
 Amicus Curiae AmicusBrf.SuppDemurrer.2.doc
   
2008-10-02

 56
 Amicus Curiae Letter to Judge Lewis
   
2008-10-07

 57
 Plaintiff Opposition to Amicus of 2008-09-12
   
2008-10-21

 58a
 Plaintiff Plaintiff's Supplemental Opposition Amicus Curiae
 
2008-11-28  58b Plaintiff Points- Authorities in Opp'n to Demurrer to FAC
       
2008-12-12

58c
 BIA Letter on tribal status by BIA to Attorney General
       
2008-12-12

 59
 Court Tentative Ruling
   
2008-12-23

 60
 Court Court isssues an Order Sustain Demurrer and Effectively Dismissing the case.
   
2009-01-06

61 a
 Plaintiff-Burley Supplemental Brief
2009-01-06

 61 b
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-01-10.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 c
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-11-12.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 d
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-13.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 e
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-14-15.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 f
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-17.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 g
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-18-20.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 h
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-21-24.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 i
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-25-26.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 j
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-27a.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 k
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-27b.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 l
 Plaintiff-Burley Woodward-Decl-Part-1.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 m
 Plaintiff-Burley Woodward-Decl-Part 4.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 n
 Plaintiff-Burley Woodward-Decl-Part 5.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 o
 Plaintiff-Burley Declaration-Corrales-Skibine.pdf
   
2009-01-16  62 Defendant Answer
   
2009-03-05   Court Order Sustaining Demurrer Without Leave to Amend

 

 

California Courts of Appeal - 4th Appellate District Division 1

California Valley Miwok Tribe v. California Gambling Control Commission

Court of Appeal Case: D054912

Symphony Towers
750 B Street, Suite 300
San Diego, California 92101
Click here for directions
and parking information.

Clerk's Office Hours: 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.

Telephone Number: (619) 645-2760 or Pat 619-645-2890

http://www.courtinfo.ca.gov/courts/courtsofappeal/4thDistrictDiv1/

Trial Court Case: 37-2008-00075326-CU-CO-CTL
 Date & Link

 #
  Agent Explanation
 2009-04-10

 1
   Notice of appeal lodged/received. filed on April 8, 2009, by California Valley Miwok Tribe
 2009-04-10

 2
   Appellate package sent.
 2009-04-10

 3
   Received copy of document filed in trial court. notice designating clerk's and reporter's filed on April 8, 2009
 2009-04-20

 4
   Civil case information statement filed. California Valley Miwok Tribe
 2009-04-23

 5
   Certificate of interested entities and parties filed by:
 2009-04-23

6
   Notice to reporter to prepare transcript. Jackie Plummer 12/12/08
 5/06/2009

 7
   Transcript fees paid.
 5/13/2009

 8
   RECORD ON APPEAL FILED.************ clerk's and reporter's
C-4(803); R-1(19);
 2009-06-09

 9
   Stipulation of extension of time filed to:
 2009-08-18

 10
   Appellant notified re failure to timely file opening brief.
 2009-08-26

 11
   APPELLANT'S OPENING BRIEF
   
2009-10-21

 12
   Defendant Reply to Opening Brief of Appellant
       
2009-11-30

 13
   Appellant-Reply-Brief
       
2009-12-03

 14
   Melnicoe-analysis
       

 

 

 
 2010-05-26

 1
  Defendant  Petition for Review by the California Gambling Control Commission.
2010-08-05

2
  Court  07/28/2010 Petition for review denied in Supreme Court. order filed in this court on 8/2/10
08/02/2010 Remittitur issued.
08/02/2010 Case complete.
08/05/2010 Record returned from Supreme Court.
       

 
 

California Courts of Appeal - 4th Appellate District Division 1

California Valley Miwok Tribe v. California Gambling Control Commission

Court of Appeal Case: D061811

Symphony Towers
750 B Street, Suite 300
San Diego, California 92101
Click here for directions
and parking information.

Clerk's Office Hours: 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.

Telephone Number: (619) 645-2760 or Pat 619-645-2890

California Courts of Appeal - http://www.courts.ca.gov/courtsofappeal.htm

Select 4th District Court of Appeal - http://www.courts.ca.gov/4dca.htm

Search - 4th Appellate District Division 1 - http://appellatecases.courtinfo.ca.gov/search.cfm?dist=41

http://appellatecases.courtinfo.ca.gov/search/case/mainCaseScreen.cfm?dist=41&doc_id=2011979&doc_no=D061811
4th Appellate District Division 1
http://appellatecases.courtinfo.ca.gov/search/case/partiesAndAttorneys.cfm?dist=41&doc_id=2011979&doc_no=D061811

http://www.courts.ca.gov/4dca.htm


Trial Court Case: 37-2008-00075326-CU-CO-CTL
 Date & Link

 #
  Agent Explanation
2012-04-23   Plaintiff PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATE AND/OR PROIDBITION OR OTHER
APPROPRIATE REUEF; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES
2012-05-02   Defendant Preliminary Opposition to writ
2012-05-21   Court Order to show cause not to remand.
2012-05-23   Intervenors Letter to Court
2012-05-23   Court Order
2012-05-24   Defendant Objection
2012-05-24   Intervenor Notes on above transactions
2012-06-15   Defendant Return to Petition for Writ
2012-06-15   Defendant Appendix to Writ
2012-06-15   Defendant Entering Roberts memorandum
2012-06-18   Intervenors Return to Petition for Writ
2012-06-28   Plaintiff Reply to Opposition
2012-07-02   Plaintiff Petition
2012-07-16   Intervenors Oral argument
2012-11-19   Court Docket
     
       


 

San Diego Superior Court - Central District

CALIFORNIA VALLEY MIWOK TRIBE

VS.

THE CALIFORNIA GAMBLING CONTROL COMMISSION

37-2008-00075326-CU-CO-CTL

Location: Hall of Justice
330 West Broadway #1100
San Diego, California 92101
http://www.sdcourt.ca.gov/

Case Type: Civil Date Filed: 01/08/2008
Category: CU-CO / Case Status: Pending
Case Category: Civil - Unlimited Location: Central
Case Type: Contract - Other Judicial Officer: Ronald L. Styn

Docket: http://www.sdcourt.ca.gov/

Case Search -> Case Number Search -> Case Type = Civil, Case Location = San Diego, Case Number, Submit -> Register of Actions

Tentataive Rulings

http://www.sandiego.courts.ca.gov/v3tr/scsdrulings.aspx

Department 62 Policies and Procedures - Honorable Ronald L. Styn
Central
Honorable Ronald L. Styn, Presiding
Department 62 Staff
Court Clerk: Kimberly Mulligan
Calendar Clerk: Pat Woods
Reporter: Susan Holthaus
Staff Attorney: Kerry Kawamura

Phone numbers
Courtroom (619) 450-7062
Calendar (619) 450-7050

Court Call - say "Pat Woods" said it is okay: instructions and 888-882-6878 (2).

Court Business Office (Civil) M-F 8:30-3:30 (619) 450-7275

 

Transcripts: Sue Holthaus 619-450-7040 sholthaus1@san.rr.com

Sue L. Holthaus, CSR 6959
San Diego Superior Court
330 W. Broadway
Department 62
San Diego, California 92101

 

San Diego Service of Process, LLC / 2445 Morena Blvd., Ste. 201 / San Diego, California 92110
Phone(s): (888) 838-8845, (619) 275-6400 Fax Number: (619) 275-6420 Email: service@sdsop.com (Jill)

WebSite: http://www.sandiegoserviceofprocess.com

(Filing fee of $35 plus check for any court fees. 3 copies for court. 1 set of documents per party served. Complete Order from on web-site for the Court and one for each Party served.)

History of filing: In the morning of 11-08-2010 the Process Server takes Notice of Motion and P&A to the Department; the Department directs them to to the Clerk, the Clerk then sends the Pleadings to the Motion Clerk, where it is being processed. In the afternoon of 11-08-2010, the Server files the Notice of Lodgement and that gets processed and posted to the web-site.

2008-07-28   Plaintiff 1st Amended Complaint
08/23/2010   Court Civil Case Management Conference
scheduled for 09/24/2010 at 10:00:00 AM at
Central in C-62 Ronald L. Styn.
09/02/2010   Court Civil Case Management Conference
rescheduled to 10/01/2010 at 10:00:00 AM
in C-62 before Ronald L. Styn at Central.
09/02/2010   Court Civil Case Management Conference
scheduled for 10/01/2010 at 10:00:00 AM at
Central in C-62 Ronald L. Styn.
10/01/2010   Court Civil Jury Trial scheduled for 05/13/2011 at
09:30:00 AM at Central in C-62 Ronald L.
Styn.
10/01/2010   Court Trial Readiness Conference (Civil)
scheduled for 06/06/2011 at 09:30:00 AM at
Central in C-62 Ronald L. Styn
10/01/2010   Court Civil Jury Trial scheduled for 05/13/2011 at
09:30AM before Judge Ronald L. Styn.
10/01/2010   Court Trial Readiness Conference (Civil)
scheduled for 06/06/2011 at 09:30AM
before Judge Ronald L. Styn.
10/01/2010   Court Jury demanded by plaintiff and defendant.
10/01/2010   Court Case file location changed to Hall of
Justice C-Civil Business Office (Rm 225)
10/01/2010   Court Minutes finalized for Civil Case
Management Conference heard 10/01/2010
10:00:00 AM
2010-10-14   Defendant Answer
10/15/2010   The California Gambling Control
Commission (Defendant)		 Answer filed by The California Gambling
Control Commission.
10/22/2010   Court Summary Judgment / Summary
Adjudication (Civil) scheduled for
01/28/2011 at 08:30:00 AM at Central in C-62
Ronald L. Styn
10/28/2010   Court Motion Hearing (Civil) scheduled for
12/17/2010 at 08:30:00 AM at Central in C-62
Ronald L. Styn.
11/01/2010   California Valley Miwok Tribe
(Plaintiff)		 Motion for Summary Judgment and/or
Adjudication (and supporting
declarations) filed by California Valley
Miwok Tribe.
11/02/2010   Court Civil Jury Trial rescheduled to 06/03/2011
at 09:30:00 AM in C-62 before Ronald L.
Styn at Central.
11/02/2010   Court Civil Jury Trial scheduled for 06/03/2011 at
09:30:00 AM at Central in C-62 Ronald L.
Styn.
11/08/2010   California Valley Miwok Tribe
(Plaintiff)		 Notice of Lodgment (of order for motion to
intervene) filed by California Valley Miwok
Tribe.
11/08/2010   Intervenors Motion for Leave to Intervene filed by
California Valley Miwok Tribe California;
Dixie, Yakima K; Whitebear, Velma; Lopez,
Antonia; Azevedo, Antone; Mendibles,
Michael; Wilson, Evelyn.
    Notice-of-Motion  Notice of Motion and Motion to Intervene
    Memorandum of Points and Authorities  Argument
    Declaration-Dixie
    Declaration-WhiteBear  
    Declaration-Lopez  
    Declaration-Mendibles  
    Declaration-Azevedo  
    Declaration-Wilson  
    Declaration-Everone  
    Proposed-Order  
    Proposed-Complaint  
    Exhibit-A 1915-08-13-SheepRanch
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1965-SheepRanch
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966-02-03.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966-02-09.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966-08-18-MabelHodgeDixie.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966-08-23.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966a-SheepRanchDoc.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966b-SheepRanchDoc.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1966c-SheepRanchDoc.pdf
    Exhibit-B Exhibit-B-1965-12-30.pdf
    Exhibit-C Exhibit-C-1925-00-00-Kroeber.pdf
    Exhibit-D Exhibit-D-2007-04-02-RegionToBurley.pdf
    Exhibit-E Exhibit-E-2010-09-10-Litigations.pdf
    Exhibit-F Exhibit-F-2005-02-11-BIA-Determination.pdf
    Exhibit-G Exhibit-G-2004-03-26-BIAtoBurley.pdf
    Exhibit-H Exhibit-H-2005-09-05-Yakima-Disenrolled.pdf
    Exhibit-I Exhibit-I-2007-04-11-BIA-PublicNotice-AmadorLedgerDispatch.pdf
    Exhibit-J Court case -not posted
    Exhibit-K Court case -not posted
    Exhibit-L Court case -not posted
    Exhibit-M Court case -not posted
    Exhibit-N  
11/09/2010   Court Trial Readiness Conference (Civil)
rescheduled to 05/06/2011 at 09:30:00 AM
in C-62 before Ronald L. Styn at Central.
11/09/2010   Court Trial Readiness Conference (Civil)
scheduled for 05/06/2011 at 09:30:00 AM at
Central in C-62 Ronald L. Styn
11/09/2010   Court Civil Court Trial rescheduled to 05/13/2011
at 09:30:00 AM in C-62 before Ronald L.
Styn at Central.
11/09/2010   Court Civil Court Trial scheduled for 05/13/2011
at 09:30:00 AM at Central in C-62 Ronald L.
Styn
11/22/2010   Court Proof of Service (Civil Case Cover Sheet;
Declarations; Applicant Intervenors' Memo
of P&As [ Terry Ladell Singleton served])
filed by The California Gambling Control
Commission.
11/22/2010   Defendant -The California Gambling Control
Commission		 Proof of Service (Civil Case Cover Sheet;
Declarations; Applicant Intervenors Memo
of P&As[ Manuel Corrales, Jr. served]) filed
by The California Gambling Control
Commission.
12/02/2010   Plaintiff - California Valley Miwok Tribe Opposition to Noticed Motion and
Supporting Declarations (to motion to
intervene) filed by California Valley Miwok
Tribe.
     
2010-12-10   Defendant -The California Gambling Control
Commission		 Defendant Objection to Plaintiff's Judicial Notice
2010-12-10   Intervenor Intervenor Reply to Opposition
2010-12-16   Court Court tentative ruling in favor of Intervention
2010-12-17   Court Hearing - court sustains tentative ruling.
       
       
2011-09-06   Plaintiff Ex Parte Papers Entry Judgement.
2011-09-06   Plaintiff Request for Judicial Notice of Determination of AS-IA
2011-09-07   Defendant Opposition-to-Ex-Parte.pdf

Below are the original proceedings which were obviated by change of jurisdiction

 50
 
2008-09-02

 51
 Defendant Demurrer
2008-09-02

 52
 Defendant Points.and.Authorities
2008-09-02

 53
 Defendant Request.for.Judicial.Notice.pdf
   
2008-09-12

 54
 Amicus Curiae Application.Leave.Amicus_PMedits.doc
2008-09-12

 55
 Amicus Curiae AmicusBrf.SuppDemurrer.2.doc
   
2008-10-02

 56
 Amicus Curiae Letter to Judge Lewis
   
2008-10-07

 57
 Plaintiff Opposition to Amicus of 2008-09-12
   
2008-10-21

 58a
 Plaintiff Plaintiff's Supplemental Opposition Amicus Curiae
 
2008-11-28  58b Plaintiff Points- Authorities in Opp'n to Demurrer to FAC
       
2008-12-12

58c
 BIA Letter on tribal status by BIA to Attorney General
       
2008-12-12

 59
 Court Tentative Ruling
   
2008-12-23

 60
 Court Court isssues an Order Sustain Demurrer and Effectively Dismissing the case.
   
2009-01-06

61 a
 Plaintiff-Burley Supplemental Brief
2009-01-06

 61 b
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-01-10.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 c
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-11-12.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 d
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-13.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 e
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-14-15.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 f
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-17.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 g
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-18-20.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 h
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-21-24.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 i
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-25-26.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 j
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-27a.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 k
 Plaintiff-Burley Exhibit-27b.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 l
 Plaintiff-Burley Woodward-Decl-Part-1.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 m
 Plaintiff-Burley Woodward-Decl-Part 4.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 n
 Plaintiff-Burley Woodward-Decl-Part 5.pdf
2009-01-06

 61 o
 Plaintiff-Burley Declaration-Corrales-Skibine.pdf
   
2009-01-16  62 Defendant Answer
   
2009-03-05   Court Order Sustaining Demurrer Without Leave to Amend
 

PLEADINGS CURRENTLY BEING TRIED, SUBSEQUENT TO THE COURT OF APPEALS
 
 2008-07-28    Plaintiff  1st Amended Complaint
       
 2010-10-14    Defendent  Defendant-Answer.pdf
       
 2013-02-20    Plaintiff Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings
 2013-02-20    Plaintiff  Motion to Deny Intervention
 2013-02-20    Plaintiff  Request for Judical Notice regarding above Motions
       
 2013-02-19    Intervenor  Request for Production of Documents.pdf
 2013-02-19    Intervenor  Requests for Admissions.pdf
 2013-02-19    Intervenor  Special Interrogatories-1-17.pdf
 2013-02-19    Intervenor  Form Interrogatories - General.pdf
       
       
 2013-03-06    Defendent  Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment.pdf
 2013-03-06    Defendent Points and Authorites.pdf
 2013-03-06    Defendent  Request for Judicial Notice 1
 2013-03-06    Defendent  Request for Judicial Notice 2
 2013-03-06    Defendent  Request for Judicial Notice 3
 2013-03-06    Defendent  Declaration of Neil Houston.pdf
 2013-03-06    Defendent  Declaration of Sylvia Cates.pdf
 2013-03-06    Defendent  Declaration of Tina Littleton.pdf
 2013-03-06    Defendent  Separate Statement.pdf
       
 2013-03-06    Intervenor Motion for Summary Judgment.pdf
 2013-03-06    Intervenor  Memorandum of Points & Authorities.pdf
 2013-03-06    Intervenor  Notice of Lodgment - Exhibits
 2013-03-06    Intervenor  Separate Statement of Undisputed Facts.pdf
 2013-03-06    Intervenor  Declaration - McConnell
 2013-03-06    Intervenor  Declaration - Robert Uram
 2013-03-06    Intervenor  Declaration - WhiteBear
       
 2013-03-07    Plaintiff  Plaintiff's Responses to Form Interrogatories.pdf
 2013-03-07    Plaintiff  Plaintiff's Responses to Request for Admissions.pdf
 2013-03-07    Plaintiff  Plaintiff's Responses to Request for Production.pdf
 2013-03-07    Plaintiff  Plaintiff's Responses to Special Interrogatories.pdf
 2013-03-07    Plaintiff  Proof of Service re Discovery Responses.pdf
       
 2013-03-11    Plaintiff  Points & Authorities in Opposition to MSJ by CGCC.pdf
 2013-03-11    Plaintiff  Points & Authorities in Opposition to MSJ by Intervenors.pdf
 2013-03-11    Plaintiff  Proof of Service re Opposition to MSJ by CGCC.pdf
 2013-03-11    Plaintiff  Proof of Service re Opposition to MSJ by Intervenors.pdf
       
 2013-03-18    Plaintiff  Request for Judicial Notice re MSJ by CGCC and Intervenors.pdf
 2013-03-18    Plaintiff  Separate Statement of Disputed & Undisputed Material Facts re MSJ by CGCC.pdf
 2013-03-18    Plaintiff  Separate Statement of Disputed & Undisputed Materials Facts re MSJ by Intervenors.pdf
       
 2013-03-25    Defendent  Defendant-CGCC's Objection to Plaintiff's Motion for Order Lifting the Effect of March 11, 2011 Order Granting Reconsideration and Denying Intervention.pdf
 2013-03-25    Defendent  Defendant-CGCC's Objections to Plaintiff's Request for Judicial Notice and to the Admissability of Exhibit 32.pdf
 2013-03-25    Defendent  Defendant-CGCC's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.pdf
       
 2013-03-27    Intervenor  Intervenor-Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.pdf
 2013-03-27    Intervenor  Intervenor-Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Order Lifting Effect of March 11, 2011 Order.pdf
 2013-03-27    Intervenor  Intervenor-Notice of Lodgment of Exhibits in Support of Intervenors' Oppositions to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.pdf
 2013-03-27    Intervenor  Intervenor-Objections to Plaintiff's Request for Judicial Notice re Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.pdf
 2013-03-27    Intervenor  Intervenor-Request for Judicial Notice and Supporting Declaration of Neil D. Houston in Support of CGCC's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.pdf
 2013-03-27    Intervenor  Intervenor-Request for Judicial Notice in Support of Intervenors' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings and Motion for Order Lifting Effect of Marc.pdf
 2013-03-27    Intervenor  Intervenor-Declaration of Matthew McConnell in Support of Intervenors' Oppositions to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings and Motion for Order Lifting Effect o.pdf
 2013-04-02    Plaintiff Declaration of Manuel Corrales in Support of Reply to Opposition by Intervenors' to Motion for Order Lifting Stay of March 11, 2011 Order.pdf
 2013-04-02    Plaintiff Plaintiff's Reply to Intervenors' Opposition to Motion for Order Lifting Stay of the Effect of the March 11, 2011 Order.pdf
 2013-04-04    Plaintiff Declaration of Manuel Corrales in Support of Reply to Defendant CGCC's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.pdf
 2013-04-04    Plaintiff Plaintiff's Reply to CGCC's Opposition to Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.pdf
 2013-04-08    Plaintiff Declaration of of Manuel Corrales in Support of Reply to Intervenors' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.pdf
 2013-04-08    Plaintiff Plaintiff's Reply to Intervenors' Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.pdf
       
 2013-04-09     Intervenor  Intervenor-Intervenors' Response to Plaintiff's Separate Statement.pdf
 2013-04-09     Intervenor  Intervenor-Reply in Support of Intervenors' Motion for Summary Judgment andor Summary Adjudication.pdf
 2013-04-09     Intervenor  Intervenor-Notice of Lodgment of Exhibits.pdf
 2013-04-09     Intervenor  Intervenor-Declaration of Matthew McConnell.pdf
 2013-04-09     Intervenor  2012-04-09-Intervenor-Proof of Service.pdf
       
 2013-04-10    Defendent  Defendant-Reply to Opposition to CGCC's Motion for Summary Judgment.pdf
 2013-04-10    Defendent  Defendant-Request for Judicial Notice and Supporting Declaration of Neil Houston.pdf
   Various intervening pleadings not posted here
 2013-07-03    Court Order dismissing Complaint and establishing right or the CGCC to withhold funds when there is a substantive doubt authority
       
 2013-07-10    Plaintiff  Appeal to the State Court of Appeals